Home - Destinations - Special Interest - Search - Editor Bios - Favorites - Kudos - Travel Shop - Feedback - Advertise

 

Drunken Fish and Why Is Fishing Best When There's Ice Cover?

By Naomi K. Shapiro

All across the northern tier of the United States, and across Canada, as lakes, impoundments and rivers freeze, millions of fisherpeople trot out their trusty tip-ups, and small rods and reels -- and -- as soon as the ice is safe enough to support their weight, move out onto the "hard water" for a chance to bring in walleye, northern, bass, panfish, perch, and whatever else is in "the neighborhood".

But have you ever wonder why fish behave the way they do under the ice?  And why do first and last ice seem to provide the best action for "hard water" anglers?  Here are some "answers" from a Wisconsin DNR News & Outdoor Report:

"Fishing is particularly good at first ice and then again near ice out...", notes Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (DNR) fisheries supervisor, Randy Schumacher, "(but) biologists don't know exactly why the fishing is so hot at first ice -- and, conversely, at ice-out -- but, they all seem to have their own theories."

Schumacher believes a combination of factors may be at work:

  • Fish know it's time to feed to get them through the hard winter ahead, so they actively feed.

  • There's more food available at this time than later in the season.

  • Ice cover prevents waves from whipping up, keeping algae and bottom sediment movement to a minimum, so fish see their prey better.

  • The clear ice (before snow cover has had a chance to block out the sun) allows a maximum amount of sunlight to reach the green plants below -- and the plants create heavy oxygenation of the water.  This oxygenation means more active fish, as the oxygen does not escape to the atmosphere.  Indeed, the fish sometimes appear to be "lightheaded" for a while -- and swim on their sides just below the new ice because of too much oxygen.  Each year, this early ice phenomenon has ice anglers reporting "drunken fish" to the DNR, Schumacher says.

  • Another reason fishing seems so good at first ice is that the fish move to warmer, deeper water, congregating in a smaller area, giving anglers more chances to catch them, and thus better fishing than usual.      

Mike Vogelsang, a DNR Fisheries Supervisor for several northern Wisconsin counties (including Vilas County), notes:  Once you get ice cover, and even a little snow, the fishing starts to heat up; but then things tail off from late January through March.  It's really dark under the ice, says Vogelsang, adding, the fish are a little less spooky; they feel a little safer with that ceiling over their head.

Recent Wisconsin DNR creel surveys show that anglers haul in some of the year's biggest walleyes in January.  Perch, bluegills, bass, and northern pike are also targets, and come late February into March, the crappies turn on big time.   As the ice melts, "holes" are formed, which allow sun-produced, heavily-oxygenated flowing water to move into these "holes", which are right under the ice.   The crappies love these warmer, oxygen-laden areas, and move high up the water column, congregating just below the ice cap.   That's why, near ice-out, mega-catches of big slab crappies often occur, literally just below the ice cap.

During the winter, and especially after snow cover has blocked sunlight from permeating the ice sheet, Vogelsang notes that, because fish are cold-blooded, their metabolism works slower, and they're slower.  Go with a lighter line, smaller hooks, and smaller bait; scale everything way down, Vogelsang advises.

As for safety, the fisheries supervisors remind ice anglers to always heed the adage: "There is no such thing as safe ice."   According to the Wisconsin DNR note, anglers choosing to venture out on the ice (especially early and late ice) need to be extremely cautious, and are advised to check with local authorities, bait shops, or area guides on ice conditions.

Top safety precautions include: Don't go out alone; carry a cell phone; wear proper clothing and equipment (including some type of flotation gear); wear creepers attached to boots to prevent slippage; carry a couple of spike nails and a length of rope; know if the water you're on has springs, inlets, outlets or narrows that have currents; and, look for clear ice, which is generally stronger than ice with air bubbles or snow cover on it. 

For more information, the Wisconsin DNR can be reached at 608-267-7517; http://dnr.wi.gov

Naomi K. Shapiro is a Madison, Wisconsin-based travel and outdoor writer specializing in fishing, nature, and soft adventure. E-mail: cre8vNaomi@charter.net

 

Copyright 1995-2008 TravelLady Magazine